Table of Contents
Introduction
The selection of the appropriate high speed tool steel is a fundamental decision that dictates the performance, longevity, and cost-efficiency of industrial cutting tools and molds. Within the high speed tool steel category, two cobalt-bearing grades often stand at a critical crossroads for manufacturers: m35 high speed steel and m42 tool steel. Both are recognized for their superior properties compared to standard high speed steels, primarily due to the inclusion of cobalt (Co). However, equating the two is a major oversight, as their subtle compositional differences lead to significant variations in mechanical performance, suitability for specific applications, and inherent cost.
Making the wrong choice between these two powerful materials introduces substantial risk—potentially leading to early tool failure, excessive manufacturing costs, or reduced precision. High speed tool steels are designed to withstand grueling conditions, including high temperatures and demanding cutting processes. Consequently, understanding the performance trade-offs inherent in the selection process is paramount to optimizing industrial outcomes. We must delve into the four critical considerations that guide experts in navigating the complexities of choosing between m35 vs m42 steel, ensuring that the final material selection aligns perfectly with operational requirements and budgetary constraints.
This guide leverages expert knowledge regarding the characteristics and applications of these two prominent high speed tool steels to provide clarity on the appropriate use cases for each grade. By focusing on intrinsic material properties, real-world application demands, and the critical balance between cost and performance, businesses can mitigate the risks associated with tool steel selection.
Critical Consideration 1: Performance Benchmarks – Hardness, Red Hardness, and the Toughness Trade-Off
The primary distinction between these two materials lies in the sophisticated balance of hardness and toughness, a defining characteristic for all high speed tool steels. M42 grade is renowned for achieving exceptionally high mechanical performance.
Why M42 tool steel Reaches Peak Hardness
M42 is specifically formulated to prioritize hardness and heat stability. The material can achieve an impressive working hardness of up to 70 HRC after appropriate heat treatment. This superior hardness is coupled with excellent heat hardness (also known as red hardness) and high temperature hardness. This capability means tools made from M42 material maintain their cutting edge integrity and strength even when operating at elevated temperatures generated by high-speed or aggressive cutting operations.
Evaluating the Role of Cobalt in M35 and M42
The inclusion of cobalt is the key differentiator for these high speed tool steel grades, placing them in the category of cobalt high speed steels. M35 is an enhancement of M2 high speed steel, featuring the addition of 5% Cobalt (Co). This addition significantly improves M35’s toughness, hardness, and wear resistance compared to M2.
M42 takes this concept further, classified as a high-cobalt toughness high speed steel (W2Mo9Cr4VCo8). It boasts an even higher cobalt content, approximately 8%. Furthermore, M42 sees a significant reduction in tungsten (W) content and an increase in molybdenum (Mo) content to around 8% compared to M35. During the quenching and heating processes, this high cobalt content facilitates greater dissolution of carbides into the matrix, which, combined with high matrix hardness, substantially enhances wear resistance. This complex alloying leads to the superior overall performance of M42 when compared directly to M35.
Assessing the Toughness Compromise
While M42 offers superior hardness, this comes with a critical caveat: its toughness is slightly compromised. Tool steel must possess sufficient toughness to resist sudden failures, such as chipping or cracking, particularly in intermittent cutting operations.
In contrast, m35 high speed steel exhibits good toughness and anti-bending strength that is not lower than ordinary high speed steel types. This resilience allows M35 material to overcome early damage issues, such as the collapsing or cracking of the mold edge. Therefore, if an application involves high impact loading, shock, or complex, delicate shapes where fracture resistance is prioritized over absolute maximum hardness, m35 high speed steel often presents a less risky choice.
What are the common failures of M42 due to low toughness?
The slightly reduced toughness of M42 means that if the application involves heavy shock or severe vibration, the cutting edge or tool structure is more susceptible to chipping or fracturing than a tougher grade like M35. This is particularly relevant in intermittent cutting applications, which is why special heat treatment methods are sometimes employed to achieve a slightly lower hardness (67-68 HRC) in M42 to enhance its impact toughness.
Critical Consideration 2: Application Suitability – Matching the Tool Steel to the Task
A crucial part of avoiding choice risk is understanding that high performance does not equate to universal suitability. The ideal choice between m35 vs m42 steel depends entirely on the material being cut, the cutting conditions, and the geometry of the tool itself.
M42, due to its exceptionally high hardness and hot hardness, is specifically manufactured for the most difficult cutting tasks.
When Is M42 the Only Option?
M42 material excels when manufacturing cutting tools designed to machine traditionally challenging materials. This includes:
- Iron-based superalloys (high-temperature alloys).
- Cast high-temperature alloys.
- Titanium alloys.
- Ultra-high strength steels.
Additionally, M42’s excellent grindability allows it to be used for complex, high-precision tools where intricate geometry is required, such as various complex cutters. It is also employed for high-toughness precision wear-resistant cold punching dies.
Why Choose M35 for General Machinability?
M35 high speed steel is classified as a general-purpose cobalt cutting tool steel. While its overall performance is generally rated lower than M42, its characteristics make it highly suitable for a broad spectrum of cutting tools and molds that require both hardness and resilience.
M35 material is recommended for manufacturing tools requiring strong cutting performance, wear resistance, and impact resistance. Specific applications include:
- Hobs.
- Broaches.
- End mills.
- Reamers and milling cutters.
- Punches and high-grade stamping dies.
If the application requires complex shapes or superior toughness to prevent cracking, M35 is often the safer, more robust choice.
Comparing Key Attributes of M35 vs M42
The following table summarizes the fundamental property trade-offs when evaluating m35 vs m42 steel for a specific project, highlighting why consultation with a professional solution provider is essential.
| Feature | m35 High Speed Steel | m42 Tool Steel |
| Primary Benefit | Good Toughness, Lower Cost, Easier Processing | Highest Hardness, Superior Red Hardness |
| Maximum Hardness | HRC 67–70 (under appropriate treatment) | Up to HRC 70 |
| Toughness | Good; not lower than standard HSS | Slightly poorer than M35 |
| Cobalt Content | Approximately 5% | Approximately 8% |
| Price | Relatively low compared to M42 | High (5-8 times common HSS) |
| Machining/Grinding | Easier to process | Good grindability; can make complex tools |
| Ideal Applications | Hobs, broaches, tools needing resilience/complex shapes | Cutting high-temp alloys, titanium, ultra-high strength steel |
| Overall Performance | Better than M2 | Superior to M35 |
Critical Consideration 3: Economic and Processing Factors – Cost and Machinability of m35 vs m42
The decision between these two high speed tool steels is rarely purely technical; economic and manufacturing realities play a significant role in mitigating commercial risk. These factors include material costs, ease of processing, and the necessity of specialized heat treatment.
Understanding the Price Premium of M42 High Speed Steel
M42 is significantly more expensive than M35 and other common high speed steels. This high cost is a direct result of its complex alloying, particularly the high cobalt content (8%). In international markets, the price of cobalt high speed steel like M42 can be 5 to 8 times that of ordinary high speed steel. Given that China has limited cobalt resources, this price disparity is a major factor in material selection.
For projects where the required material properties slightly exceed those of M35 but do not absolutely necessitate M42’s extreme hardness, the cost savings offered by m35 high speed steel can be substantial. M35 is noted for being relatively low-cost.
The Impact of Machinability on Production Efficiency
Processing tool steel often involves extensive cutting, machining, forging, and heat treatment. The ease with which a material can be shaped contributes directly to the overall production cost and lead time.
M35 is described as being relatively easy to process. This characteristic makes it highly attractive for manufacturers aiming for streamlined production and increased efficiency. Suppliers often provide comprehensive processing services, including specialized cutting and machining, to further improve the efficiency of these processes.
Conversely, M42’s process is generally more complex due to its specific alloy ratios. While it possesses good grindability, which aids in manufacturing complex tools, the necessary heat treatment processes require precise control. Specifically, due to M42’s slightly reduced toughness, the quenching temperature must be precisely controlled and should utilize the lower limit of the recommended range.
Is M35 cheaper because of lower quality?
No. M35 is a high-quality cobalt high speed steel with excellent comprehensive properties, including high hardness and toughness. It is less expensive than M42 primarily because M42 contains a higher percentage of costly cobalt (8% vs. 5%) and has a more complex overall alloy composition, resulting in a higher price premium. M35 remains a superior performance choice compared to standard M2 grades.
How do processing services reduce risk for M42?
Because M42 requires strict heat treatment parameters (such as using the lower limit of quenching temperature) and specific machining techniques to maximize tool life, relying on a supplier that offers professional processing services—including heating, forging, and heat treatment—reduces the risk of improper handling and material failure. Suppliers like Shandong Qilu Industrial Co., Ltd. offer custom processing services to enhance efficiency and ensure quality.
Critical Consideration 4: Quality Assurance and Expert Consultation
Regardless of whether a manufacturer selects m35 high speed steel or m42 tool steel, the quality of the raw material and the precision of the manufacturing and processing services are critical to the final tool performance. The inherent risks in tool steel selection extend beyond mechanical properties to sourcing reliability and metallurgical expertise.
The Role of EAF or ESR Smelting in Tool Steel Quality
The process by which the steel is manufactured significantly impacts its final quality, durability, cutting performance, and heat treatment stability. Professional suppliers often specify the smelting method, such as EAF (Electric Arc Furnace) or ESR (Electroslag Remelting). These methods ensure that the tool steel, whether M35 or M42, is meticulously forged to meet the stringent demands of high-performance applications. Choosing a supplier with reliable equipment and advanced production processes is essential to obtaining superior quality tool steel products and solutions.
Tailoring Solutions Based on Production Process
The ultimate performance of the tool is achieved not just through the steel grade itself, but through the highly specialized processing it undergoes. Experienced tool steel providers understand that one size does not fit all. They offer professional customization and specialized processing services—including cutting, machining, and heat treatment—to meet distinct product needs.
When facing the m35 vs m42 steel decision, consulting experts allows manufacturers to leverage extensive experience in the steel industry. Experts possess a deep understanding of the characteristics, strengths, and weaknesses of these various tool steels. They can provide tailored advice based on the intended use, the specific production process, required strength metrics, and the customer’s budget.
Why is professional customization necessary for M35 vs M42?
Professional customization is necessary because the intended application may require a blend of properties that only precise processing can achieve. For instance, a manufacturer might need the high wear resistance of M42 but require specialized heat treatment (like using the lower limit quenching temperature) to improve impact toughness for a specific type of intermittent cut. Professional customization services ensure that the steel is processed accurately to enhance durability and precision, mitigating the risk of material failure under operational stress.
How does Qilu support material selection?
Shandong Qilu Industrial Co., Ltd., which has over 30 years of experience in the steel industry, is described as a professional tool steel and mold steel solution provider. They offer professional customization and processing services to improve efficiency and stock common tool steel products (including m35 and m42) to provide fast delivery. Their team of experts has a deep understanding of tool steels and can assist customers in research and development, providing solutions based on intended use, production process, required strength, and budget.
Conclusion
The choice between m35 vs m42 steel is a classic example of balancing highly desirable but mutually exclusive characteristics: absolute hardness versus superior toughness. M42 delivers the ultimate performance in terms of high-temperature hardness and wear resistance, making it essential for machining difficult materials like titanium and superalloys. Conversely, m35 high speed steel offers a highly effective, cost-efficient solution with better innate toughness and easier processability, mitigating the risk of failure in tools requiring complex shapes or moderate impact resistance.
Avoiding risk requires a structured approach focused on the four critical considerations outlined: understanding the precise performance benchmarks, ensuring the steel grade matches the application suitability, analyzing the economic and processing factors, and securing quality assurance and expert consultation. For manufacturers, relying on knowledgeable partners who offer professional customization and have a deep inventory of both m35 and m42 tool steel grades allows them to receive solutions tailored exactly to their intended use, required strength, and budget, ensuring optimized performance and reduced operational risks.
FAQ
The technical nature of choosing between m35 vs m42 steel often leads to practical questions about daily usage and operational limits. Here are some commonly asked questions reflecting real-world selection dilemmas:
How does the performance of m35 high speed steel compare to standard M2?
M35 high speed steel represents a significant performance upgrade over M2. By incorporating 5% cobalt into the M2 base, M35 achieves higher toughness, increased hardness, and improved wear resistance. It also boasts good red hardness, allowing tools to maintain performance when subjected to heat. M35 is generally placed in the performance hierarchy above M2 but below M42.
Is m42 tool steel difficult to grind?
Despite its very high hardness, M42 is noted for having good grindability. This is a major advantage, as it means that M42 can be used to manufacture complex, high-precision tools, such as various cutters, without excessive difficulty during the final shaping and sharpening stages.
Which steel is better for cutting titanium alloys: M35 or M42?
M42 is definitively preferred for cutting titanium alloys, as well as super high-strength steel and iron-based high-temperature alloys. M42’s superior high-temperature hardness and wear resistance are crucial for success in these highly demanding operations. While M35 is a powerful steel, M42’s higher cobalt content and overall mechanical performance make it the material of choice for such aggressive material removal tasks.
If I prioritize tool life in general cutting, which steel should I use?
If maximizing tool life under extreme heat and severe wear conditions is the absolute priority, M42 is the superior choice due to its high hardness and superior hot hardness. However, if the cutting involves intermittent operations or heavy impacts, and early tool failure (chipping/cracking) is a major concern, M35’s better inherent toughness might actually result in a longer usable tool life by preventing catastrophic failure. The decision requires balancing wear resistance (M42) against impact resistance (M35).
Why must M42 use the lower quenching temperature limit?
M42 must employ the lower limit during quenching because its intrinsic toughness is slightly poorer than M35. Precise temperature control during heat treatment is critical to optimize its properties and minimize the risk of brittleness or cracking in the final tool.
If you enjoyed this blog on mechanical parts processing, don’t forget to join me on social media for more insights, updates, and community discussions.
📘 Facebook – Connect with me here
Let’s keep exploring, learning, and growing together. Thanks for reading, and see you in the next post! 🚀
